Skip to main content

Criminal Procedure Law - Appeals

This guide provides an overview of the appeals process in India's Criminal Procedure Law, tailored for law students and LLB candidates.

Introduction

Appeals play a crucial role in the criminal justice system, allowing defendants to challenge convictions and prosecutors to seek higher sentences. This chapter explores the key aspects of appeals under the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) 1973.

Types of Appeals

First Appeal

The first appeal is filed against the judgment of the Sessions Court. It is typically heard by the High Court.

Legal Section: Section 378 CrPC

Example Case: Rameshwar Prasad vs. State of Bihar (1952 SCR 452)

In this landmark case, the Supreme Court held that the High Court should not interfere with the acquittal unless there was a manifest error of law apparent on the face of the record.

Second Appeal

The second appeal is filed against the judgment of the High Court. It is usually heard by the Supreme Court.

Legal Section: Section 379 CrPC

Example Case: Kalyan Chandra Sarkar vs. Rajesh Ranjan (2005 SCC OnLine SC 166)

The Supreme Court ruled that the second appeal could be entertained only if there was a substantial question of law ascertained by the High Court.

Grounds for Appeal

An appeal can be filed on various grounds, including:

  1. Error of law
  2. Misdirection in law
  3. Wrong decision on a point of law
  4. Abuse of discretion by the trial court

Legal Section: Section 384 CrPC

Example Case: State of Maharashtra vs. Sohanlal Valji Vyas (1987 SCC OnLine Bom 273)

The Bombay High Court upheld an appeal where the trial court had misdirected itself on the interpretation of a crucial piece of evidence.

Time Limit for Filing Appeal

The time limit for filing an appeal varies depending on the type of appeal:

  • First Appeal: Within 90 days from the date of judgment
  • Second Appeal: Within 120 days from the date of judgment

Legal Section: Section 386 CrPC

Example Case: State of Punjab vs. Gurmit Singh (2010 SCC OnLine SC 1239)

The Supreme Court dismissed an appeal filed after the expiry of the statutory period, emphasizing the importance of adhering to time limits.

Conclusion

Understanding the appeals process in criminal procedure law is essential for law students and practicing lawyers. This guide provides a foundation for navigating the complexities of appeals in India's legal system.

Remember to consult the full text of the Criminal Procedure Code and relevant case laws for comprehensive understanding.